Around Thanksgiving, the kitchen gets busy and another chair is pulled up to the table as we reflect on the way things used to be. If Pembroke Historical Society Curator Alan Gianatassio is in that chair you will learn much.
I was fortunate enough to sit with Gianatassio at the Pembroke Historical Society, as he described a Native population once far larger than the one encountered by later English settlers. He also spoke of people traveling here from the Blue Hills south of Boston.
Long before there was a town called Pembroke, Native families fished its ponds, tended planting grounds and knew the paths through its woods. As we give thanks for food, family and a place to call home, their story belongs in our thoughts, too.
Those two points open a door onto a much older Pembroke, where the seasons helped set the household calendar.
The local Mattakeeset people were part of the broader Massachusett world. Their pond settlement was known as Namassakeesett, commonly translated as “place of much fish.” For anyone who has watched a good herring run, that name needs little explaining. [1]
The spring herring run was a reason to return. So were planting grounds, game and the other resources of the woods and water. The ponds belonged to a working landscape, connected to neighboring communities by waterways and well-used paths. [2]
Gianatassio’s account of the Blue Hills connection has a parallel in the Sullivan Family Foundation’s history of the nearby River House. It describes Native people wintering in the Blue Hills and coming toward Pembroke in spring to fish and hunt. [3]
The Massachusetts Historical Commission’s Pembroke survey describes another seasonal pattern: families living around the inland ponds during colder months and traveling toward Duxbury and Marshfield for coastal food during spring and summer. It also identifies a travel corridor linking the North River, Pembroke’s ponds and Plymouth Bay. [2]
The accounts differ about winter quarters. They may reflect different families, periods or parts of a wider seasonal round; that is a possibility, rather than an established explanation. What they do suggest is that we should picture paths traveled back and forth, with the ponds an important stopping place and home ground.
Our familiar Thanksgiving story takes us a little farther down the road, to Plymouth. In the fall of 1621, English colonists and Wampanoag people, including their leader Ousamequin, often called Massasoit, took part in a harvest celebration. Edward Winslow’s account tells of three days of feasting and five deer brought by the Wampanoag. [8]
That gathering gives us a lasting picture of people sharing food after a hard year. Pembroke’s Mattakeeset history is a distinct part of the region’s Native story; we should not assume its families were the people at that Plymouth feast.
And the country around them had already suffered a terrible change.
European fishermen and traders were visiting these shores before the Mayflower arrived. With those encounters came unfamiliar diseases. Between 1616 and 1619, an epidemic devastated coastal Native communities in what became southeastern Massachusetts. The losses are often remembered as the Great Dying. They came before the harvest gathering we remember at Thanksgiving. [4, 5]
Pilgrim Hall Museum reports estimates that the Wampanoag lost between 75% and 90% of their population. At Patuxet, where Plymouth was later established, nearly the entire community died. Those figures describe neighboring Wampanoag history; they are not a census of Pembroke’s Mattakeeset people. [4]
There is no reliable local count that lets us say how many people lived around Pembroke’s ponds before the epidemic, or exactly how many died. Researchers also continue to debate the disease responsible for the 1616–1619 outbreak. [2, 5]
Still, Gianatassio’s larger point matters. The English who settled here encountered a region already shaken by devastating loss. A place with fewer people than it once held was still somebody’s home.
Over the generations that followed, English settlement brought further pressure on Native land and livelihoods.
Wampatuck, a sachem associated with the ponds, appears in accounts of the Major’s Purchase of 1662. According to the North and South Rivers Watershed Association, about 1,000 acres beside the ponds were retained for him and his descendants. Queen Patience, whom the association identifies as his granddaughter, later held land on Furnace Pond and sold it before her death in 1788. [1]
Here the history meets a story Pembroke has kept telling.
In an old, published legend, Patience is called Sunny Eye. When her people leave after sickness and hardship, she stays behind at Furnace Pond. That account belongs to folklore, and its dramatic details should be read as such. [6]
Even so, it is easy to understand why the image stayed with people: an elderly woman remaining beside familiar water while the world around her changes.
We can remember that story while also looking beyond it. Patience was part of a longer Native history, and that history continued after her lifetime. The Mattakeeset Tribe’s own account emphasizes the survival of its people, their traditions and their identity into the present. [7]
This Thanksgiving, as the dishes make their way around the table, perhaps there is room for one more local story.
Tell the children about the herring returning in spring. Tell them about the old paths connecting the Blue Hills, the ponds and the coast. Tell them about Queen Patience, remembered beside Furnace Pond, and about the Native people who continue to carry their history today.
We have much to be thankful for in Pembroke: the water, the woods, our families and neighbors. Learning who knew and cared for these places before us is one way of showing that gratitude.
The Pembroke Historical Society, 116 Center St., on Friday, Nov. 6, at 4 to 7 p.m. and Saturday, Nov. 7, at 9 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. will have a free Open House and Holiday Market.
Admission is free and for the nominal fee of $5 you can take a photo with Santa on Saturday.
Sources
Interview with Alan Gianatassio.
1. North and South Rivers Watershed Association, “Furnace Pond Beach.” https://www.nsrwa.org/listing/furnace-pond-beach/
2. Massachusetts Historical Commission, Pembroke reconnaissance survey (1981), especially report pages 2–3. The survey distinguishes probable seasonal patterns from documented locations and provides no specific early local population total. https://www.sec.state.ma.us/divisions/mhc/preservation/survey/town-reports/archives/pem.pdf
3. Sullivan Family Foundation, The 1715 River House, “Our Story Starts 10,000 Years Ago,” printed pages 2–3. This local historical account describes winter residence in the Blue Hills and spring travel to Pembroke; it does not establish a single original migration or a pattern followed by all families. https://sullivanfamilyfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/RiverHseBro7x10-Web-6-5-2023.pdf
4. Pilgrim Hall Museum, “The Great Dying.” Its Wampanoag mortality estimates should not be applied as a measured Mattakeeset or Pembroke death rate. https://www.pilgrimhall.org/the-great-dying/
5. John S. Marr and John T. Cathey, “New Hypothesis for Cause of Epidemic among Native Americans, New England, 1616–1619,” Emerging Infectious Diseases 16(2), 2010. The proposed diagnosis is a hypothesis, not a settled identification. https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/16/2/09-0276_article
6. Charles M. Skinner, American Myths and Legends, Volume 1, “The Evil Doing of Hobomoc.” Used only as evidence of a published legend. Its supernatural events and infected-blanket allegation are not treated here as verified local history. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/American_Myths_and_Legends/Volume_1/The_Evil_Doing_of_Hobomoc
7. Mattakeeset Tribe, mission statement and “Our Story.” https://www.mattakeeset.com/ and https://www.mattakeeset.com/history
8. Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian, “Treaty and Harvest Celebration,” including Edward Winslow’s contemporary account. https://americanindian.si.edu/nk360/Thanksgiving/sq4ss1.html
Research distinction: the Blue Hills-to-Pembroke account describes seasonal movement, not a demonstrated original migration into the region. The state survey supports links toward Plymouth Bay and seasonal travel to Duxbury and Marshfield. A regular Pembroke-to-Narragansett migration was not established by the sources reviewed.